If the AI Bubble Bursts: What Happens to Fintech and Payments?

The AI hype train has been running full steam ahead in fintech for the past few years, but cracks are already starting to show. With 42% of companies having scrapped the majority of their AI projects by early 2025: up from just 17% a year earlier: we're witnessing the early signs of what could become a full-blown bubble burst.

So what happens when the music stops? The answer isn't pretty, but it's not the apocalypse either. Let's dive into the real-world implications for fintech and payments if this bubble finally pops.

The Current Reality Check

Before we explore the aftermath, let's acknowledge where we stand today. The fintech AI gold rush has produced more fool's gold than the real thing. Between 70% and 85% of generative AI deployments are falling short of ROI expectations, and here's the kicker: only 47% of AI initiatives are actually turning a profit, whilst 14% are generating negative returns.

This isn't just about disappointing quarterly reports. We're talking about billions in misallocated capital, inflated valuations built on AI promises that haven't materialised, and a growing realisation that many AI applications in financial services were solutions looking for problems.

The Immediate Carnage: Who Gets Hit First

When the bubble bursts, the damage won't be evenly distributed. The first casualties will be the "AI-first" fintech startups that built their entire value proposition around artificial intelligence. These companies, many of which raised funding at astronomical valuations based on AI potential rather than proven results, will face severe funding crunches.

Venture capital will dry up faster than water in the Outback. Investors who've been burned by AI promises will become incredibly risk-averse, making it nearly impossible for struggling AI-focused fintechs to secure bridge funding or follow-on rounds.

The human cost will be significant. Layoffs across the sector will be swift and deep, particularly hitting data scientists, AI engineers, and product managers who specialised in AI implementations. Companies will right-size their operations, keeping only the profitable, non-AI core functions.

Infrastructure Meltdown: The Hidden Costs Surface

Here's something most people aren't talking about: the massive infrastructure bubble that's been built to support AI operations. Data centres scaled up to handle AI workloads will suddenly become expensive white elephants. The computing power that costs a fortune to maintain will have no profitable use cases to justify the expense.

This infrastructure contraction will be particularly painful for established financial institutions that invested heavily in integrating AI into their legacy systems. Banks and payment processors that borrowed or stretched their capital to build AI capabilities will face significant write-downs and stranded assets.

The ripple effects will extend to cloud providers, specialised AI hardware manufacturers, and even commercial real estate markets where data centres are located. It's a cascade of interconnected failures that will amplify the initial shock.

Payment Processors: Back to Human Reality

The payments sector will experience some of the most visible changes post-bubble. Customer service operations will undergo a dramatic shift as companies realise that AI-driven support often creates more problems than it solves.

Take Klarna's experience as a cautionary tale. Their shift to AI-driven customer service failed spectacularly when the system consistently delivered inaccurate answers, maintained a robotic tone, and created confusion around escalations. Customers dealing with payment disputes, fraud cases, or complex transaction issues need human empathy and contextual understanding: not algorithmic responses.

Companies will be forced to rebuild human-staffed support teams, dramatically increasing operational costs. The lean, AI-powered customer service model that many payment companies adopted will prove unsustainable when customer satisfaction plummets and regulatory scrutiny increases.

However, it won't be a complete reversion. Basic transaction processing, fraud detection, and risk assessment: areas where AI has demonstrated clear ROI: will likely maintain automated assistance. The key difference will be knowing where to draw the line between human and machine capabilities.

The Regulatory Reckoning

Financial regulators, who've been watching the AI experiment with growing concern, will likely use the bubble burst as justification for stricter oversight. Expect comprehensive AI governance frameworks, mandatory impact assessments for AI implementations in financial services, and requirements for human oversight in critical decision-making processes.

This regulatory response will add another layer of cost and complexity for fintech companies trying to navigate the post-bubble landscape. Compliance teams will need to grow, and companies will need to invest in governance systems they previously ignored in their rush to implement AI solutions.

What Survives the Wreckage

Not everything AI-related will disappear when the bubble bursts. The technologies and applications with genuine utility will survive and even thrive in the new environment.

Open-source AI models will continue improving and become accessible at a fraction of current costs. Fintech companies that focused on hybrid models: using AI to augment human capabilities rather than replace them entirely: will emerge stronger and more competitive.

Successful applications will be those with measurable ROI and clear value propositions: fraud detection systems that actually reduce losses, compliance tools that genuinely streamline regulatory reporting, and risk assessment models that improve lending decisions. These use cases will continue attracting investment and development.

The Consolidation Wave

A bubble burst typically triggers industry consolidation, and fintech won't be immune. Weak players with unsustainable AI strategies will either exit the market or get acquired by stronger competitors at fire-sale prices.

This consolidation might actually benefit consumers and the industry in the long run. Resources will be concentrated in companies with proven business models and sustainable competitive advantages. The market will reward actual innovation over AI buzzword bingo.

Preparing for the Reset

Smart fintech leaders are already preparing for this scenario. They're conducting honest assessments of their AI investments, identifying which initiatives deliver genuine value, and building sustainable business models that don't depend on AI magic.

The companies that will thrive post-bubble are those investing in hybrid approaches, maintaining strong human capabilities alongside selective AI implementation, and focusing on solving real customer problems rather than showcasing technological sophistication.

The Silver Lining

While a bubble burst will be painful, it will ultimately serve as a much-needed reality check for the fintech industry. Investment will flow toward proven use cases rather than speculative applications. Customer service will improve as companies balance efficiency with human empathy. And the industry will emerge leaner, more focused, and genuinely innovative rather than just AI-washed.

The fintech sector has survived numerous bubbles and downturns before. The AI bubble burst won't kill innovation: it will redirect it toward sustainable, valuable applications that genuinely improve financial services.

---

Navigating the complex landscape of fintech innovation and preparing for industry shifts requires expert guidance. If you're looking to future-proof your fintech strategy or need insights on sustainable technology investments, I'd love to help. Visit kianjackson.com to learn more about how we can work together, or reach out directly to discuss your specific challenges and opportunities.